A search for CP violation in the phase space of the decay $D^+\to\pi^\pi^+\pi^+$ is reported using $pp$ collision data, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 1.0 fb$^{1}$, collected by the LHCb experiment at a centreofmass energy of 7 TeV. The Dalitz plot distributions for $3.1\times 10^6$ $D^+$ and $D^$ candidates are compared with binned and unbinned modelindependent techniques. No evidence for CP violation is found.
Invariantmass distributions for (a) $ D ^+$ and (b) $ D ^+_ s $ candidates in the momentum range $50<p_{ D ^+ _{(s)}}\!\!<100$ $ {\mathrm{\,GeV\!/}c}$ for magnet up data. Data points are shown in black. The solid (blue) line is the fit function, the (green) dashed line is the signal component and the (magenta) dotted line is the background. 
Fig1a.pdf [27 KiB] HiDef png [256 KiB] Thumbnail [76 KiB] *.C file 

Fig1b.pdf [28 KiB] HiDef png [258 KiB] Thumbnail [76 KiB] *.C file 

Dalitz plots for (a) $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ and (b) $ D ^+_ s \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ candidates selected within $\pm2\tilde\sigma$ around the respective $\tilde m$ weighted average mass. 
Fig2a.pdf [33 KiB] HiDef png [590 KiB] Thumbnail [149 KiB] *.C file 

Fig2b.pdf [31 KiB] HiDef png [492 KiB] Thumbnail [137 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Distribution of $\mathcal{S}_{CP}^i$ with 49 $ D ^+_ s $ adaptive bins of equal population in the $ D ^+_ s \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ Dalitz plot and (b) the corresponding onedimensional distribution (histogram) with a standard normal Gaussian function superimposed (solid line). 
Fig3a.pdf [137 KiB] HiDef png [228 KiB] Thumbnail [72 KiB] *.C file 

Fig3b.pdf [14 KiB] HiDef png [109 KiB] Thumbnail [50 KiB] *.C file 

Dalitz plot for $ D ^+_ s \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ control sample decays divided into (a) seven regions R1R7 and (b) three regions P1P3. Region R3 is further divided into two regions of $s_{\rm high}$ at masses smaller (R3l) and larger (R3r) than the $\rho^{0}(770)$ resonance. 
Fig4a.pdf [81 KiB] HiDef png [561 KiB] Thumbnail [112 KiB] *.C file 

Fig4b.pdf [80 KiB] HiDef png [543 KiB] Thumbnail [109 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Pull values of $T$ and (b) the corresponding pvalues for $ D ^+_ s \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ control sample candidates restricted to each region, obtained using the kNN method with $n_k=20$. The horizontal blue lines in (a) represent $3$ and $+3$ pull values. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig5a.pdf [58 KiB] HiDef png [115 KiB] Thumbnail [55 KiB] *.C file 

Fig5b.pdf [58 KiB] HiDef png [139 KiB] Thumbnail [62 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Raw asymmetry $A=(N_N_+)/(N_+N_+)$ and (b) the pull values of $\mu_T$ for $ D ^+_ s \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ control sample candidates restricted to each region. The horizontal lines in (b) represent $+3$ and $+5$ pull values. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig6a.pdf [47 KiB] HiDef png [134 KiB] Thumbnail [4 KiB] *.C file 

Fig6b.pdf [58 KiB] HiDef png [120 KiB] Thumbnail [56 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Pull values of $T$ and (b) the corresponding pvalues for the background candidates restricted to each region obtained using the kNN method with $n_k=20$. The horizontal blue lines in (a) represent $3$ and $+3$ pull values. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig7a.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [112 KiB] Thumbnail [55 KiB] *.C file 

Fig7b.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [139 KiB] Thumbnail [61 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Raw asymmetry and (b) pull value of $\mu_T$ as a function of a region for the background candidates. The horizontal lines in (b) represent $+3$ and $+5$ pull values. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig8a.pdf [28 KiB] HiDef png [136 KiB] Thumbnail [63 KiB] *.C file 

Fig8b.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [118 KiB] Thumbnail [55 KiB] *.C file 

Distributions of $\mathcal{S}_{CP}^i$ across the $ D ^+$ Dalitz plane, with the adaptive binning scheme of uniform population for the total $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ data sample with (a) 49 and (c) 100 bins. The corresponding onedimensional $\mathcal{S}_{CP}^i$ distributions (b) and (d) are shown with a standard normal Gaussian function superimposed (solid line). 
Fig9a.pdf [247 KiB] HiDef png [172 KiB] Thumbnail [68 KiB] *.C file 

Fig9b.pdf [14 KiB] HiDef png [104 KiB] Thumbnail [48 KiB] *.C file 

Fig9c.pdf [250 KiB] HiDef png [186 KiB] Thumbnail [74 KiB] *.C file 

Fig9d.pdf [14 KiB] HiDef png [109 KiB] Thumbnail [48 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Distribution of $\mathcal{S}_{CP}^i$ with 98 bins in the uniform binning scheme for the total $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ data sample and (b) the corresponding onedimensional $\mathcal{S}_{CP}^i$ distribution (b) with a standard normal Gaussian function superimposed (solid line). 
Fig10a.pdf [225 KiB] HiDef png [164 KiB] Thumbnail [65 KiB] *.C file 

Fig10b.pdf [14 KiB] HiDef png [103 KiB] Thumbnail [45 KiB] *.C file 

Dalitz plot for $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ candidates divided into (a) seven regions R1R7 and (b) three regions P1P3. 
Fig11a.pdf [146 KiB] HiDef png [1 MiB] Thumbnail [153 KiB] *.C file 

Fig11b.pdf [145 KiB] HiDef png [1 MiB] Thumbnail [152 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Raw asymmetry and (b) the pull values of $\mu_T$ for $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ candidates restricted to each region. The horizontal lines in (b) represent pull values $+3$ and $+5$. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig12a.pdf [47 KiB] HiDef png [137 KiB] Thumbnail [60 KiB] *.C file 

Fig12b.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [120 KiB] Thumbnail [55 KiB] *.C file 

(a) Pull values of $T$ and (b) the corresponding pvalues for $ D ^+ \!\rightarrow \pi ^ \pi ^+ \pi ^+ $ candidates restricted to each region obtained using the kNN method with $n_k=20$. The horizontal blue lines in (a) represent pull values $3$ and $+3$. The region R0 corresponds to the full Dalitz plot. Note that the points for the overlapping regions are correlated. 
Fig13a.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [111 KiB] Thumbnail [54 KiB] *.C file 

Fig13b.pdf [57 KiB] HiDef png [138 KiB] Thumbnail [61 KiB] *.C file 

Animated gif made out of all figures. 
PAPER2013057.gif Thumbnail 
Results for the $D^+ \rightarrow \pi^\pi^+\pi^+$ decay sample using the adaptive binning scheme with different numbers of bins. The number of degrees of freedom is the number of bins minus 1. 
Table_1.pdf [29 KiB] HiDef png [77 KiB] Thumbnail [12 KiB] tex code 
Created on 16 February 2019.Citation count from INSPIRE on 21 February 2019.