A study of $D^+\pi^$, $D^0 \pi^+$ and $D^{*+}\pi^$ final states is performed using pp collision data, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 1.0 $fb^{1}$, collected at a centreofmass energy of 7 TeV with the LHCb detector. The $D_1(2420)^0$ resonance is observed in the $D^{*+}\pi^$ final state and the $D^*_2(2460)$ resonance is observed in the $D^+\pi^$, $D^0 \pi^+$ and $D^{*+}\pi^$ final states. For both resonances, their properties and spinparity assignments are obtained. In addition, two natural parity and two unnatural parity resonances are observed in the mass region between 2500 and 2800 MeV. Further structures in the region around 3000 MeV are observed in all the $D^{*+}\pi^$, $D^+\pi^$ and $D^0 \pi^+$ final states.
Modified GodfreyIsgur mass predictions \cite{Godfrey:1985xj}. The figure shows the $c\bar{u}$ spectrum in which the masses have been scaled such that the ground state coincides with the $D^0$ mass. The $2^$ states, not shown in the original publication, have been inserted following the splitting structure of the 1P states. 
fig1.pdf [13 KiB] HiDef png [137 KiB] Thumbnail [53 KiB] *.C file 

Invariant mass distribution for (a) $ D ^+ \rightarrow K^\pi^+\pi^+$, (b) $ D ^0 \rightarrow K^\pi^+$, and (c) $ D ^{*+} \rightarrow D ^0 \pi ^+ $ decays. The solid lines are the results from the fits described in the text. The vertical dashed lines indicate the signal regions. 
fig2.pdf [31 KiB] HiDef png [323 KiB] Thumbnail [211 KiB] *.C file 

Invariant mass distribution for (a) $ D ^+ \pi ^ $, (b) $ D ^0 \pi ^+ $ and (c) $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ candidates (points). The full line histograms (in red) show the wrongsign mass spectra for (a) $ D ^+ \pi ^+ $, (b) $ D ^0 \pi ^ $ and (c) $ D ^{*+} \pi ^+ $ normalized to the same yield at high $D^{(*)}\pi$ masses. 
fig3.pdf [39 KiB] HiDef png [418 KiB] Thumbnail [472 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum, {\it enhanced unnatural parity sample}, as defined in Table ???. The dashed (blue) line shows the fitted background, the dotted (red) line the $ D_1(2420)^0$ contribution. The inset displays the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum after subtracting the fitted background. The full line curves (blue) show the contributions from $ D_{J}(2580)^0$ , $ D_{J}(2740)^0$ , and $ D_{J}(3000)^0$ states. The top window displays the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. The pull is defined as $(N_{\rm data}  N_{\rm fit})/\sqrt{N_{\rm data}}$. 
fig4.pdf [71 KiB] HiDef png [319 KiB] Thumbnail [229 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the {\it natural parity sample} $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum. The dashed (blue) line shows the fitted background, the dotted lines the $ D_1(2420)^0$ (red) and $ {D}^*_2(2460)^0$ (blue) contributions. The inset displays the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum after subtracting the fitted background. The full line curves (red) show the contributions from $ D_{J}(2580)^0$ , $ D_{J}(2740)^0$ , and $ D_{J}(3000)^0$ . The dotted (blue) lines display the $ D^*_{J}(2650)^0$ and $ D^*_{J}(2760)^0$ contributions. The top window shows the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. 
fig5.pdf [76 KiB] HiDef png [337 KiB] Thumbnail [240 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the {\it unnatural parity sample} $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum. The dashed (blue) line shows the fitted background, the dotted lines the $ D_1(2420)^0$ (red) and $ {D}^*_2(2460)^0$ (blue) contributions. The inset displays the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum after subtracting the fitted background. The full line curves (red) show the contributions from $ D_{J}(2580)^0$ , $ D_{J}(2740)^0$ , and $ D_{J}(3000)^0$ states. The dotted (blue) lines display the $ D^*_{J}(2650)^0$ and $ D^*_{J}(2760)^0$ contributions. The top window shows the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. 
fig6.pdf [74 KiB] HiDef png [333 KiB] Thumbnail [241 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the total $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ sample. The dashed (blue) line shows the fitted background, the dotted lines the $ D_1(2420)^0$ (red) and $ {D}^*_2(2460)^0$ (blue) contributions. The inset displays the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum after subtracting the fitted background. The full line curves (red) show the contributions from $ D_{J}(2580)^0$ , $ D_{J}(2740)^0$ , and $ D_{J}(3000)^0$ states. The dotted (blue) lines display the $ D^*_{J}(2650)^0$ and $ D^*_{J}(2760)^0$ contributions. The top window shows the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. 
fig7.pdf [72 KiB] HiDef png [329 KiB] Thumbnail [236 KiB] *.C file 

Distributions of (a) $ D_1(2420)^0$ and (b) $ {D}^*_2(2460)^0$ candidates as functions of the helicity angle $\cos\theta_{\rm H}$ . The distributions are fitted with unnatural and natural parity functions, respectively. 
fig8.pdf [17 KiB] HiDef png [99 KiB] Thumbnail [51 KiB] *.C file 

Distributions of (a) $ D^*_{J}(2650)^0$ and (b) $ D^*_{J}(2760)^0$ candidates as functions of the helicity angle $\cos\theta_{\rm H}$ . The distributions are fitted with natural parity (black continuous), unnatural parity (red, dashed) and $J^P=0^$ (blue, dotted) functions. 
fig9.pdf [20 KiB] HiDef png [203 KiB] Thumbnail [192 KiB] *.C file 

Distributions of (a) $ D_{J}(2580)^0$ , (b) $ D_{J}(2740)^0$ and (c) $ D_{J}(3000)^0$ candidates as functions of the helicity angle $\cos\theta_{\rm H}$ . The distributions are fitted with natural parity (black continuous) and unnatural parity (red, dashed) functions. In (a) the $J^P=0^$ (blue, dotted) hypothesis is also tested. 
fig10.pdf [22 KiB] HiDef png [188 KiB] Thumbnail [144 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the $ D ^+ \pi ^ $ mass spectrum. The filled histogram (in red) shows the estimated crossfeeds from the high mass $ D ^* \pi$ resonances. The dashed (blue) line displays the fitted background. The dotted (blue) line shows the $ {D}^*_2(2460)^0$ contribution. The inset displays the mass spectrum after the fitted background subtraction. The full (blue) curves show the $ D^*_{J}(2760)^0$ and $ D^*_{J}(3000)^0$ contributions. The top window displays the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. 
fig11.pdf [76 KiB] HiDef png [307 KiB] Thumbnail [229 KiB] *.C file 

Fit to the $ D ^0 \pi ^+ $ mass spectrum. The filled histogram (in red) shows the estimated crossfeeds from the high mass $ D ^* \pi$ resonances. The dashed (blue) line displays the fitted background. The dotted (blue) line shows the $ {D}^*_2(2460)^+$ contribution. The inset displays the mass spectrum after the fitted background subtraction. The full (blue) curves show the $ D^*_{J}(2760)^+$ and $ D^*_{J}(3000)^+$ contributions. The top window displays the pull distribution where the horizontal lines indicate $\pm 3 \sigma$. 
fig12.pdf [76 KiB] HiDef png [291 KiB] Thumbnail [218 KiB] *.C file 

Animated gif made out of all figures. 
PAPER2013026.gif Thumbnail 
BreitWigner parameters describing the crossfeed from $ D_1(2420)$ and $ D^*_2(2460)$ in the $ D ^+ \pi ^ $ and $ D ^0 \pi ^+ $ final states. 
Table_1.pdf [37 KiB] HiDef png [44 KiB] Thumbnail [20 KiB] tex code 

Definition of the categories selected by different ranges of $\cos\theta_{\rm H}$ , and fraction of the total natural parity contribution. 
Table_2.pdf [49 KiB] HiDef png [39 KiB] Thumbnail [15 KiB] tex code 

Mass intervals, number of bins, yields, and $\chi^2/{\rm ndf}$ in the fits to the different mass spectra. 
Table_3.pdf [58 KiB] HiDef png [65 KiB] Thumbnail [27 KiB] tex code 

Resonance parameters, yields and statistical significances. The first uncertainty is statistical, the second systematic. Significances are evaluated using the method described in the text. 
Table_4.pdf [55 KiB] HiDef png [105 KiB] Thumbnail [45 KiB] tex code 

Results from the fits to the $\cos\theta_{\rm H} $ angular distributions for the resonances observed in the $ D ^{*+} \pi ^ $ mass spectrum. The resulting $\chi^2/{\rm ndf}$ for different spinparity assignments are reported. For each resonance, the expected angular distributions are indicated, where $h$ is a free parameter. The favoured spinparity assignment is indicated in bold font. 
Table_5.pdf [64 KiB] HiDef png [87 KiB] Thumbnail [41 KiB] tex code 
Created on 11 July 2020.